Home page
About Us          Leadership          Services          News          Weblog          Contact Us
Strategic Public Relations To Make Your Business Bloom
 
 

Monday, July 31, 2006

Newspaper Reporters Are Our Heroes -- in the Movies, Anyway

From the Washington Post:

With occasional exceptions, newspaper people usually get the hero treatment in movies and TV shows. This is in sharp contrast to TV reporters, who are just as likely to be trashed. TV journalists might be prettier and better paid in real life than their ink-stained brethren and sistren, but on screen there's no contest about who comes off better...

Sure, newspaper reporters in the movies can be a cynical, tough-talking, hard-drinking bunch who aren't above cutting a few corners to get the story ([Scarlett]Johansson's character, for example, sleeps with two of her sources in "Scoop." But all is forgiven when they expose the truth.)...

TV reporters? They're not nearly as lucky. Television journalists tend to be depicted as fatuous pretty boys and girls, mostly out for career advancement. The truth? Not only can't they handle it, it's not even very important. Think of William Hurt's character in "Broadcast News" (1987) or Bill Murray's cynical weatherman in "Groundhog Day" (1993), or more recently, "Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy" (2004). The most devastating portrait of all might be the deranged TV newsman Howard Beale (Peter Finch) in the satirical "Network" (released the same year that Woodward and Bernstein were being lionized in "All the President's Men").

We're not crying for the TV reporters. Have you ever seen a single positive portrayal of a PR practitioner on film? Us neither.

Here, by the way, is our list of the Top 10 Films About Journalism and/or PR. We'll drag it out again in case anyone would like to discuss it -- even though we don't expect Scoop to alter it:

1. Citizen Kane
2. Capote
3. Sweet Smell of Success
4. Network
5. All the President's Men
6. Broadcast News
7. His Girl Friday
8. Good Night, and Good Luck
9. The Insider
10. Wag the Dog

3 Comments:

  • I again chastise you for the missing "A Face in the Crowd."

    And "The Paper" deserves at least an honorable mention.

    By Anonymous Mike Orren, at 7/31/2006  

  • I used to have the Paper in the list, but Good Night knocked it out.

    By Blogger SB, at 7/31/2006  

  • The most positive portrayals of "PR" folks I can think of come from Aaron Sorkin in The American President, and its little-known TV spinoff The West Wing.

    Second best would be the White House press secretary in Dave - where the spineless PR guy with a heart of gold helps the Kevin Kline character boot nasty Frank Langela out of the White House.

    By Anonymous Eric E, at 7/31/2006  

Post a Comment

<< Home



 

 
Copyright 2006 Idea Grove