Home page
About Us          Leadership          Services          News          Weblog          Contact Us
Strategic Public Relations To Make Your Business Bloom
 
 

Sunday, March 19, 2006

The Amazing Orchardo Predicts: Google Will Lose Its Secrecy Battle


The Amazing Orchardo, our prognosticating alter ego, is as unequivocally certain about this prediction as he was about his last one. He's just not sure this one will come true as quickly as that one has.

If you haven't heard, a Web site called Kinderstart.com is suing Google for downgrading its PageRank "without reason or warning." Kinderstart is demanding that Google release information on how it ranks its search results. PageRank, of course, is Google's version of the Colonel's secret recipe.

We suspect Google will win this one, just as it appears to be heading off the U.S. government's request that it hand over keywords and Web addresses.

But Orchardo believes that whatever the law says, the time will come when the public no longer accepts Google's secrecy.

The public has different expectations for companies that become dominant in their markets and, as a result, assume a big role in our lives. Dominance -- rather than any corporate misstep -- is the reason for the backlash Microsoft began receiving after its Windows 95 peak, and it is the reason for the backlash Wal-Mart is receiving today.

These companies' policies -- their approach to business -- hasn't changed dramatically over the years; in fact, you could argue that the reason for their success has been their remarkably consistent adherence to their corporate values. It's the expectations that have changed.

Hence, we get a Bill Gates who was heavily criticized for not giving to charity 10 years ago ... and who is now Time's Person of the Year for his philanthropy. And we have a Wal-Mart that -- when all is said and done -- will likely change some of its traditionally penurious labor practices to shore up its public image.

Frankly, we much prefer Technorati's transparent ranking system to Google's PageRank mumbo-jumbo, which has birthed a cottage industry of charlatans and witch doctors who charge companies an arm and a leg to mysteriously boost their Google rankings.

That's soooo Web 1.0, Google. Oh well -- enjoy your secret handshakes while they last.

Technorati tags: , , ,

5 Comments:

  • Re Kinderstart's lawsuit.
    This is a brilliant PR move on Kinderstart's part. Their server is probably smoking from all the blog generated traffic this news is creating. PT Barnum would be proud. You can read more on my blog about a similar experience with the mighty Goog.

    By Anonymous Peter, at 3/19/2006  

  • So, why didn't they also do likewise with the other search engines?

    And what is not clear to me is if this is through Adsense, or just what Google says is their station in the life of the web?

    I agree with Peter...just a good publicity stunt.

    By Anonymous Alan Weinkrantz, at 3/19/2006  

  • It may be a publicity stunt, but I think it reflects the frustrations of many Web site operators. Google would be unwise to ignore it.

    By Blogger SB, at 3/19/2006  

  • Alan,

    They aren't suing Yahoo for two reasons.

    1. Yahoo probably delivers about one-tenth of the traffic that google does, so why bother going after it?

    2. Kinderstart's rankings on Yahoo and MSN are probably far better than on Google.

    It's Google that's doing the damage.

    By Anonymous Peter, at 3/19/2006  

  • good site

    By Anonymous Cruise, at 12/10/2006  

Post a Comment

<< Home



 

 
Copyright 2006 Idea Grove