A Book Recommendation for Tom Foremski

Ten years ago, Stuart Ewen’s book PR! A Social History of Spin was published. Ewen offers a stridently leftist take on the PR industry (he doesn’t like us), but it’s also a fascinating read.
One of my favorite parts is seeing what the newspaper editors of the early 20th century had to say about Ivy Lee [pictured], who is now considered, along with Edward Bernays, one of the “fathers” of the public relations industry. Describing one of Lee’s campaigns,
The Toledo Blade reported that “throughout the Colorado troubles, pamphlets, circulars and letters fairly rained down upon the newspapers. It was a flood, a deluge. If it converted or influenced anyone, we have not heard of it.
“A broad reading of the American press indicated that the stuff went into the waste baskets throughout the country just as it did here. It swelled the postal receipts and added to the tonnage of houses that buy waste paper. But as for education, there was no result at all.”
Fast forward to 2006 and the editor of the Silicon Valley Blade:
Press releases are created by committees, edited by lawyers, and then sent out at great expense through Businesswire or PRnewswire to reach the digital and physical trash bins of tens of thousands of journalists.
This madness has to end. It is wasted time and effort by hundreds of thousands of professionals.
Thanks for continuing to play such a “disruptive role in mainstream PR,” Tom. What’s your next big idea — the steam locomotive?
Technorati tags: PR, Public Relations, Marketing



Jeez, it is Silicon Valley Watcher not Silicon Valley Blade and all I did was to say that the press release format needs to be changed, deconstruct it so I can reconstruct it, give me some links, give me some relevant links elesewhere. You’d think I said something about PR people’s mothers the way they have reacted…well, I’m on the bullet train you guys are still on the steam train.
Yeah, we’re a sensitive bunch.
Full steam ahead.
Can you at least get Silicon Valley Watcher right? It is not Silicon Valley Blade.
Sorry; that was just a little joke.
People know your pub by rep, Tom, and I respect you and Silicon Valley Watcher.
I just thought the tone in your various posts instructing the PR industry on how to reform itself was a little condescending — like we’re a bunch of dopes who can’t see the writing on the wall.
I don’t think that’s the case, so I’m just having a little fun in making my point.
Thanks for keeping us on our toes, though. You’ve definitely stirred up some useful conversation.